In the Clinic

On Cancer: Poking Holes in Cancer — One Electric Current at a Time

By Jim Stallard, MA, Writer/Editor  |  Monday, January 27, 2014
Pictured: Stephen Solomon Interventional Radiologist Stephen Solomon

Cancer researchers constantly strive to expand the arsenal of weapons to treat the disease, particularly for people with tumors that aren’t responsive to conventional treatments. One such option is a minimally invasive approach called thermal ablation, which involves placing a needle into a tumor and applying extreme heat or cold, which kills the cancer while preserving healthy tissue. In addition to destroying tumors, thermal ablation may actually activate immune cells to attack the cancer.

Memorial Sloan Kettering now has one of the biggest ablation programs in the United States, says Stephen Solomon, Chief of the Interventional Radiology Service and Director of the Center for Image-Guided Interventions. “We’re treating approximately 300 people a year, frequently on an outpatient basis that allows patients to go home after the procedure the same day.”

However, thermal ablation cannot be used in some patients.

“Thermal ablation can cause scarring in healthy tissue near the tumor, making it inappropriate for use on some tumors near blood vessels, nerves, bile ducts, and other sensitive structures,” says Mikhail Silk, a medical student at SUNY Downstate College of Medicine, in Brooklyn, who is conducting research in collaboration with the Interventional Radiology Service. “It also can fail to kill every cancer cell if the tumor abuts a major blood vessel because blood flow dissipates some of the extreme heat or cold emitted from the needle — a phenomenon called the heat sink effect.”

Punching Holes in Cells

Now a new, minimally invasive treatment that uses an electric current to punch tiny holes in cancer cell membranes is showing promise against challenging tumors. Called irreversible electroporation (IRE), the technique uses tiny needles to give cancer cells a jolt of electricity. 

The electricity produces holes in the cell membranes, which disrupts the balance of molecules inside and outside the cells. IRE causes no scarring or inflammation in nearby healthy tissues, and there is no heat sink effect.

“Blood vessels and nerves are made not just of cells but also have protein structures surrounding them,” Dr. Solomon explains. “Because proteins don’t have electric membrane potential, these structures are largely protected from IRE, making it possible to destroy a tumor safely without destroying the structural integrity of an organ.”

IRE holds particular potential for treating liver, lung, and pancreatic cancers that are close to blood vessels and other sensitive structures — situations in which normal heat or cold ablation is not feasible.

Encouraging Study Results

After validating the safety of IRE in animal studies, Memorial Sloan Kettering’s interventional radiologists and surgeons have begun using the procedure in select patients who are not eligible for other treatments — particularly, patients with cancer that has spread to the liver from other sites in the body.

Early results suggest IRE can be effective and safe. In the January 2014 issue of the Journal of Vascular Interventional Radiology, Dr. Solomon’s team reports that IRE was used successfully in 11 patients to treat a total of 22 small tumors that had spread to the liver from other locations. In 15 treatment sessions, the tumors — which had a median size of 3 centimeters — were destroyed with no major complications. Many of the tumors were located less than 1 centimeter from bile ducts, making thermal ablation too risky.

Memorial Sloan Kettering specialists will continue to explore IRE in other types of cancer, although in every case it needs to be compared with thermal ablation and other minimally invasive treatments. Dr. Solomon’s team recently received a grant from the National Institutes of Health to investigate the use of IRE in lung cancer, which they hope to begin in 2014.

A strong feature of the Interventional Radiology Service has been the addition of a biomedical engineer, Govind Srimathveeravalli, who has worked with the clinical team to optimize the use of IRE.

“For complete tumor destruction with IRE, it is important to achieve a uniform electric field within the target region,” Dr. Srimathveeravalli says. “As tumors are heterogeneous in nature, treatment planning for IRE can be a challenge to physicians. I use physics simulations and work with Dr. Solomon to develop guidelines for optimizing treatment plans. We also perform research to develop new devices that will extend the reach of IRE therapy to new anatomical locations.”

“Our research program will be focusing a lot of energy on developing and refining IRE over the next few years,” Dr. Solomon adds. “There are still important questions that need to be answered — such as whether IRE actually destroys all the cancer cells — but we hope it becomes another tool that physicians can rely on when nothing else is suitable.” 

Comments

Can this be used on tumors in the brain

Mary,

This technology is still experimental and it is too early to say which types of cancer it will be effect in treating.

Thank you for your comment.

What is it about liver, lung, and pancreatic cancers that makes IRE hold a particular potential for treating?

Elizabeth,

IRE could be useful for these cancers because they are often located near blood vessels, nerves, and other sensitive structures that could be damaged by other treatments such as surgery or thermal ablation.

Thank you for your comment.

what about a primary tumor as opposed to a metastatic tumor?

Pat, thank you for your comment. We consulted with Dr. Solomon on your question and he responded:

Yes. Primary tumors have been treated as well. This is still an early time for the technology and there is still a lot to learn. Our efforts are primarily in cases where we have few other options.

Would this treatment work on small cell cancer

Keith, the technology is still experimental and it is too early to say which types of cancer it will be effective in treating. It is currently being used in cases where doctors have few other options.

Thank you for your comment.

I couldn't be more proud of my son, Gordon Single, product manager for AngioDynamics, for working with your team. This will revolutionize the treatment of cancer thanks to your fine work!

I was diagnosed with Stage IV Colon / Liver cancer in June of 2013. I've finished round 11 of chemotherapy and will soon reach number 12. At that point, my medical team will decide if I'm to receive liver directed chemo, radiation implants to the liver, or just continue on maintenance chemo program?

I'm very interested in the possibility of this procedure in the very near future if its available now for use?

I am insured, and am willing to do what ever is necessary for a second chance at life.

Jeff, thank you for your comment. If you would like to make an appointment with a Memorial Sloan-Kettering physician, please call our Physician Referral Service at 800-525-2225 and explain the details of your situation or go to http://www.mskcc.org/cancer-care/appointment.

Greetings. My mother is a 58 years old female. She has recurrent/rectal cancer at 1 cm from anal verge. She had TAE/TAMIS on 7/16/2013. Pathology 3 cm tumor, T2 (invades through muscular propria, + LVI, no LN seen) T2NXMX, distal margin + on September 2013, she had a colostomy for colonic obstruction. On January 31, 2014, she was subjected to a Laparascopic APR with Lymphadenectomy. Unfortunately, this wasn't concluded since apparent
metastasis (Pelvis) was present (No Vital organs at this point). She has been referred for Chemotherapy.

My question is. Is she a possible candidate for IRE? We are ready to travel since we are from Puerto Rico. Please let us know. We are so anxious with all this situation.

v/r

Dear Felix, we are sorry to hear about your mother's recurrence of rectal cancer. The technology is still experimental and it is currently being used in cases where doctors have few other options.

If you would like to make an appointment for your mother to have a consultation with one of our physicians, please call our Physician Referral Service at 800-525-2225.

Thank you for reaching out to us.

does the procedure work on lymph nodes?

Judy, thank you for your comment. We consulted with Dr. Solomon and he responded:

"We have done lymph nodes but it depends where they are and how they fit into the overall clinical picture."

Peri portal lymph node?

Judy, Dr. Solomon responds regarding use of IRE on peri portal lymph node:

It would depend on the case.

Great work! keeping the bad guys out of the human body is a challenging task. when that challenge is met effectively, lasting joy and contentment is what stays with a former patient who might have been hopeless prior to treatment. My current focus is the human heart. I am not an expert, but the materials that I consult gives me knowledge that I did not really acquire during my bio courses. Congrats! if you would allow me to. I hope the IRE technique proves to be effective for the targeted major organs.

My wife has a metastatic melanoma stage IV. There are multiple metastasis - however, the most dangerous are on liver and on spine that causes stenosis. She is on anti-PD1 trial. May IRE be helpful for her?

Dear Eugene, we are sorry to hear about your wife's diagnosis. We cannot answer personal medical questions on the blog, but in general, the technology is still experimental and it is too early to say which types of cancer it will be effective in treating. It is currently being used in cases where doctors have few other options.

If your wife would like to make an appointment for a consultation with one of our physicians, please call our Physician Referral Service at 800-525-2225.

Thank you for reaching out to us.

Can I.R.E. be performed on soft tissue mass around the spine? Thought to be Metastatic PC?

Patricia, we consulted with Dr. Solomon on your question and he responded:

It will depend on the images. Most lesions are small and have some distance from the spinal cord. We would also consider radiation.

Can you, please, tell little more about possibility o using this technology for brain tumors - what do you think about it? Did you try it or may be theoretically planing? It is have some hope - becouse it still no big progress in the brain tumor treatments and it is very important to create new possibility for that. What do you think about it? Thank you!

Elena, thank you for reaching out to us. In general, this technology is still experimental and it is too early to say which types of cancer it will be effective in treating, including brain tumors. It is currently being used in cases where doctors have few other options.

If your wife would like to make an appointment for a consultation with one of our physicians, please call our Physician Referral Service at 800-525-2225.

Thank you for reaching out to us.

Do you have some new information from January? I understand that it is experimental and just would know do you plan to try it for brain tumors and how Doctor see it possibility. Thank you very much!

Elena, thank you for your comment. We consulted with Dr. Solomon and he responded:

I am familiar with dog brains being treated with IRE, but not with humans. Dr. Philip Gutin (of MSK) has a project using electric fields for brain tumors (ie. Novocure).

Thank you very much!

My 2.5 yo daughter was just diagnosed with Stage IV Alveolar Rhabdomyosarcoma by Texas Childrens in Houston. She has 3 masses, one near her rib cage, another near her kidney and a small area near a rib that has not done any damage to the bones. The larger of the 2 is near her ribs and is less than 5CM. Would it be possible to use this method to damage the 2 tumors enough to cause them to stop growing/initiate apoptosis? She has not been treated with Chemo medicines or radiation yet and I have been researching medical data that could be used to treat her specific type of cancer without damaging her immune system. They want to start treatment on Monday. Can you provide me with more information about this procedure. I understand its experimental but there have been no other alternatives presented to me besides textbook answers off the cancer.org site.

Derrick, we consulted with Dr. Solmon and he responds:

We have ablated sarcomas before. IRE is a form of ablation that might be considered, however, I would suggest they discuss with their treating physicians about the appropriate options for their daughter.

Follow-up: We advised the oncology team at Texas Childrens to get in contact with you and they said no one from your hospital has called them back. We gave them the direct link to this post for reference after you responded to my question. Is there a direct contact that we can forward them to in regards to consultation?

Derrick, we recommend that you have the oncology team contact our Physician Referral Service at 800-525-2225 and explain the specifics of the case and that they are seeking a consultation with an MSK expert regarding this type of procedure. Thank you for your comment.

My mom is under the care of Dr. Strong Surgen and Dr. Olsen oncologist for stage four stomach cancer that has spread to her colon and liver after opening her two weeks ago to remove tumor from her stomach that was originally diagnose as stage two stomach cancer. I would like Doctor Solomon opinion and consultation to see if his new IRE will benefit my mother.
Thank you
Frank Landivar Son

Frank, thank you for reaching out. We suggest your mother consult with her physicians about a consultation with Dr. Solomon and the possible use of IRE for her case.

I have been diagnosed with prostate cancer in 2010. Gleason score 3+3.
I am on active surveillance at Sloan.
Do you think I will be a candidate for either thermal ablation or IRE.
If so will Dr. Solomon do it, or my present Dr. Ehdaie?

Robert, unfortunately we are not able to answer individual medical questions on our blog. We suggest that you speak with your current MSK physician about this. Thank you for your comment.

My Mother has bile duct cancer that has spread to her liver and has multiple tumors on her liver. Her bile duct is not blocked. This treatment sounds like an option for her. Who can we speak to to see if this is an option for her?

Dear Jasmin, we are sorry to hear about your mother's diagnosis. To make an appointment with one of our specialists and discuss appropriate treatment options, please call our Physician Referral Service at 800-525-2225. Thank you for reaching out to us.

Hi Doctors, thank you for your dedicated service and thank you for taking my question. I have small cell cancer which was discovered approximately 3 years ago and my Dr. is somewhat surprised at my survivability. The tumor is where my bronchial tubes branch out (the crux) and it has responded reasonably well to chemo up to this point. Because it has begun to grow my Dr. feels the is present chemo is not effective. My Dr. says the cancer is not acting the way small cell cancer normally acts. The tumor is pressing directly on one bronchial tube and partially on a second one inhibiting breathing to some extent. The next move he is suggesting, after having consulted with a pulmonologist ( I also have consulted on one occasion and a second is scheduled) that a stent(s) be placed in the bronchial tubes and a direct injection of chemo into the tumor by going through the bronchial tube and directly into the tumor. Have you had experience in this direct injection procedure and it's effectiveness or do you think the IRE procedure would be more effective? Thank you so much for taking time to review and answer my question. Take care.
Sincerely,
Mike Bolduc

Dear Mike, thank you for reaching out to us. Unfortunately, we cannot give personal medical advice over our blog. If you would like to make an appointment with one of our interventional radiologists, you can call 800-525-2225 or you can get appointment information here: http://www.mskcc.org/cancer-care/appointment. Thanks again for your question.

Is there anyone doing this on metastatic breast cancer tumors in the bone. I have two that are causing trouble: a painful one in my upper arm, and also one at the base of the skull that is causing some numbness in my face.

And/or can you recommend someone who does this in Washington/Oregon. Or I could come to NYC.

Thank you!

Dear Meg, we reached out to Dr. Solomon about your question. He had this to say: "Yes we do this, however, the one at the skull base may be too difficult. We would need to review imaging. They may be able to help at Oregon Health Sciences Center." If you'd like to make an appointment at Memorial Sloan Kettering, the number is 800-525-2225, or you can learn more here: http://www.mskcc.org/cancer-care/appointment. Thanks so much for your question, and we wish you all the best.

Thank you for your reply. Do you have a name at OHSU? I'm not finding anyone by calling and asking. Thanks!

Dr. Solomon suggests you try Ken Kolbeck at the Dotter Interventional Institute: http://www.ohsu.edu/dotter/kolbeckk.htm

can this be done on someone using immune suppressants 5 yrs post liver transplant? Lung cancer?

Linda, we cannot answer specific medical questions on the blog, but in general, the technology is still experimental and it is too early to say which types of cancer it will be effective in treating.

If you'd like to make an appointment for a consultation with one of our physicians, please call our Physician Referral Service at 800-525-2225. Thank you for your comment.

Is turmeric helpful with tumor shrinkage?

Linda, you can learn more about turmeric on our About Herbs database. You'll find it here: http://www.mskcc.org/cancer-care/herb/turmeric Thank you for your comment.

My Mother's records have been sent there to be in a trial for bile duct cancer, we are waiting on an appointment, which we should have in the next day or two. I am looking to see if her records could be shared with the Doctors who are practicing this therapy to see if this could work for her.

Jasmine, you can follow up with the physician's office once the appointment is made to ask about having the records shared. Thank you for your comment.

Do I request that they get shared with Dr. Solomon?

Add a Comment

We welcome your questions and comments. Because this is a public forum, please do not include contact information or other personal details. Also, keep in mind that while we can provide general information and resources, we cannot offer personal medical advice. To make an appointment with one of our experts, contact our Physician Referral Service at 800-525-2225 or online.
Your e-mail address is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

More information about formatting options