On Cancer: When "Do No Harm" Means "Do Nothing": Evolving Protocols

Vincent Laudone Urologic surgeon Vincent Laudone

Our conversation about active surveillance of prostate cancer continues. In previous posts James Eastham and I wrote about the benefits this management strategy offers some patients and how we manage risks. Recently a reader asked what the protocol is for selecting and following patients on active surveillance.

In fact, our protocol is constantly evolving. One reason for this is that we continually gain new information by analyzing patients who have been on active surveillance to date. We now have experience managing more than 1,000 patients with prostate cancer on active surveillance for up to ten years.

Choosing the Right Approach for Each Patient

From this experience, we have learned that the most important factor in achieving a successful outcome for patients on active surveillance is to be certain from the very beginning that their cancer is appropriate for this approach. For this reason we now routinely do a prostate MRI at the time of initial diagnosis, and, if indicated, a second or “confirmatory” biopsy.

In addition, the recent availability of genomic testing now gives us an enhanced ability to better assess the aggressiveness of an individual cancer based on DNA analysis of the biopsy samples. Taken together, all of this information is used to determine which patients are good candidates for active surveillance and which patients should receive immediate treatment.

Following Patients

When it comes to following patients on active surveillance, advances in MRI technology —including stronger magnets and better software — continue to reduce the need for repeat prostate biopsies over time. The information gained over the past several years along with the technological improvements now allow us to individualize the follow-up regimen for each patient, tailoring the schedule to fit the aggressiveness of the cancer and the patient’s characteristics, such as age and health status. Most men on active surveillance are seen every six months for a routine exam and PSA check, with follow-up MRI and biopsies as circumstances warrant.

Finally, our experience gained thus far has given us reason to consider active surveillance not only for very low-volume, low-grade disease but also for a broader group of patients, including men with higher-volume Gleason grade 6 disease, or even low-volume Gleason grade 7 disease. 

Vincent P. Laudone is a urologic surgeon specializing in robotic surgery.


Is an MRI done to determine if cancer is present before doing a biopsy?

Dear Anthony, we sent your inquiry to MSK surgeon Dr. Vincent Laudone and he responded:

"This is a good question. The use of prostate MRI has being increasing in
recent years as the technology has improved and we have gained more
experience interpreting the results of the MRI images. Memorial Sloan Kettering has been a leader in the use of prostate MRI for more than a decade. Most recently, technology has been developed that allows for the MRI images to be incorporated into the ultrasound procedure used to obtain a prostate
biopsy (known as "MRI fusion biopsy"). This enables us to precisely target any abnormalities seen on the MRI during the biopsy procedure. Several hundred of these MRI fusion biopsies have been performed at MSKCC with excellent results. Given the availability of this enhanced technology, we are now doing prostate MRIs in most patients prior to prostate biopsy. In must be realized, however, that doing an MRI adds significantly to the cost of diagnosis, and that the MRI alone cannot be used without the biopsy to make a diagnosis. Lastly, not all patients can have an MRI if they are claustrophobic, have a pace maker, or certain other internal metal items."

If you would like to make an appointment with a specialist at Memorial Sloan Kettering, please contact our Physician Referral Service at 800-525-2225. Thank you for reaching out to us.

Add a Comment

We welcome your questions and comments. Because this is a public forum, please do not include contact information or other personal details. Also, keep in mind that while we can provide general information and resources, we cannot offer personal medical advice. To make an appointment with one of our experts, contact our Physician Referral Service at 800-525-2225 or online.
Your e-mail address is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

More information about formatting options