Communicating health and cancer risks in contexts where there is high uncertainty

Many of our projects directly address the challenges of uncertainty in the cancer context, including how oncologists communicate about uncertainty with their patients, how patients make decisions when faced with risk information and uncertain outcomes, and patterns in uncertainties about cancer risk in the general public by levels of health literacy, education, avoidance, and other characteristics. Our work has implications for intervention development across clinical and public health contexts, and basic social science theory of how people cope with uncertainty in health contexts, and in cancer care, most specifically.

Some example projects are:

Addressing low awareness of the cancer harms of alcohol in the population

Risk perceptions encompass individuals’ appreciation of their personal lifestyle, environmental, and genomic cancer risk factors. Uncertainty about one’s cancer risks has often gone unmeasured in standard assessments of cancer risk perceptions, with “don’t know” or “no idea” responses treated as missing data, or not allowed for at all. Our team has documented population-based estimates of high uncertainty about colorectal cancer risk perception, and the prevalent response “don’t know” regarding the cancer risks of alcohol consumption. I lead a team examining predictors for high uncertainty about the cancer risks of drinking alcohol, and developing messages to address uncertainty as well as inaccurate beliefs about alcohol risk and cancer. 

Supporting Test Result Interpretation and Variant Education (STRIVE) Study

Dr. Hamilton and her collaborator Dr. Kenneth Offit are conducting an ongoing trial focused on improving the care quality and engagement with genetic counseling services among patients with variant of uncertain significance (VUS) results in cancer predisposition genes. VUS are common, particularly as multigene panel testing is increasingly used and encompasses greater numbers of genes. Prior studies have shown that patients and clinicians often do not understand VUS findings and can make incorrect recommendations, including risk-reducing surgeries, based on VUS findings.